Skip to content
ATC
  • Events
    • Australasian Talent Conference 2025
    • Talent Leader Long Lunches
  • Content
    • TWIT
    • Articles
    • Watch On-Demand
  • Talent Tech
  • Get Involved
  • About
  • Events
    • Australasian Talent Conference 2025
    • Talent Leader Long Lunches
  • Content
    • TWIT
    • Articles
    • Watch On-Demand
  • Talent Tech
  • Get Involved
  • About

Talent pooling – myth or silver bullet?

Mobility & ODBy Bo Kai LowApril 30, 2019Leave a comment

By now, everyone gets the need for proactive recruiting. TA needs proactive strategies to align with your organisation’s people strategy, hiring needs and to compete for top talent. Additionally, digital transformation and disruption are pushing many companies to recruit in areas where their brands are not particularly well-known. Talent pooling is touted as the strategic…

ATC
Contact Us

info@atcevent.com

Linkedin-in Youtube
Aboriginal and torres strait islander flags

The ATC team work on many lands including those of the Bunurong, Wurundjeri-Willam and Dharawal people. We also host events in Naarm, Kulin and Eora Nations and beyond. We thank the Traditional Custodians and Elders of all of the lands that we live and work on for their continued care of land and waters.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer

© 2024 ATC Events 

Menu
  • About
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Agenda test
  • ATC 2024 Agenda
  • ATC Digital Sponsorship – Terms & Conditions
  • ATC Events’ General Ticketing Terms & Conditions
  • ATC Lunch Sponsorship – Terms & Conditions
  • ATC TA Brew Terms & Conditions
  • ATC2023 – Exhibitor Resources
  • ATC2024 Drop In Expo Ticket T&Cs
  • ATC2024 Event App
  • ATC2024 Exhibitor Onsite Resources
  • ATC2024 Exhibitor Resources
  • ATC2024 Exhibitor Terms & Conditions
  • ATC2024 Expo – How to Get There
  • ATC2024 How to Get There
  • ATC2024 How to Get There
  • ATC2024 Ticketing Terms & Conditions
  • ATC2025 Exhibitor Terms & Conditions
  • ATC2025 Ticketing Terms & Conditions
  • Blog
  • Blog
  • Book your 2 free tickets to TA Brew – Melbourne
  • Book your free ticket to TA Brew – Melbourne
  • Bringing the TA community together
  • Community
    • Contribute! Share with the Community
  • Contact Us
  • Content
  • Contingent Workforce Forum Ticketing Terms & Conditions
  • Contingent Workforce Survey 2025
  • Contribute to the Wisdom of the TA Crowd
  • CWF2025 – Event Info
  • CWF2025 Agenda
  • Digital Event: Unpacking the 2020 State of TA Download
  • Disclaimer
  • Download our Digital Media Kit
  • Download the 2021 State of Talent Acquisition Report
  • Download The Perfect Fit Whitepaper
  • Download Unilever Case Study
  • Downloadables Guides
  • Dr. Bree Gorman’s Recruitment Bias Checklist
  • Elementor #41781
  • Email Link
  • Future of Talent (FoT) Terms & Conditions
  • Get Involved
    • Talent Practitioners
    • Solution Providers
    • Launching New Talent Tech?
  • Graduate recruitment leaders competition
  • Insights
  • Latest articles
  • Latest News
  • Playbacks
  • Present your Talent Story at ATC2024
  • Privacy Policy
  • Reach our Audience
  • Register for webinar: Personal Brand Masterclass with Ruby Lee
  • Register your interest for TA Brew
  • Register your interest for TA Brew 2023 – Melbourne
  • Register your interest for the Long Lunch Series
  • Register your interest for the Long Lunch Series
  • Register your interest for the Talent Lunch
  • Reserve your seat for Talent Leaders Lunch – Brisbane
  • Resources
  • Resources coming soon
  • RSVP – Register My Attendance for the Talent Leaders’ Lunch, Melbourne
  • RSVP – Register My Attendance for the Talent Lunch, Melbourne
  • RSVP – Register My Attendance for the Talent Lunch, Sydney
  • Sample Page
  • Sign Up
  • Sign up to TWIT & the museletter
  • Speak, Sponsor, or Exhibit at ATC 2024
  • Sponsorship Opportunities
  • Subscribe to the Museletter
  • TA Brew 2023 – Event Information
  • TA Brew 2024 – Vendor Engagement Opportunities
  • TA Brew Melbourne – Event Information
  • TA Brew Sydney – Event Information
  • TA Careers
  • Talent Advisory Conference Terms & Conditions
  • Talent Tech
  • Talent Tech / Find A Supplier Terms & Conditions
  • Talent Tech Listing Submission
  • Thanks for subscribing
  • The ATC COVIDSafe Plan
  • The Brightest Minds in Talent in One Exciting Place
  • TWIT
  • Write For Us
  • “Freelancer = Contractor” Competition
  • Shop
    • Cart
    • Checkout
    • Account
    • Login
  • Contact
  • Terms & conditions
  • Cookie policy
  • Demo design system
  • Maintenance page

2024 Innovation Lab: Talent Tech Pitch Off

By now, everyone gets the need for proactive recruiting. TA needs proactive strategies to align with your organisation’s people strategy, hiring needs and to compete for top talent.
Additionally, digital transformation and disruption are pushing many companies to recruit in areas where their brands are not particularly well-known.
Talent pooling is touted as the strategic solution, but is it working for you?

Three Kinds of Talent Pool Quagmire

One, and perhaps this situation sounds familiar: you are dutifully sourcing candidates for future openings, and maybe you even make your first hire. Only a few months later, the requirements for the next hire in that job family have changed, and the same candidates who were a good fit just three months ago are no longer right for the role.
Many companies find it difficult to keep up with changing business and candidate needs, and as a result the talent pools being built might be too narrow to meet evolving needs. Or perhaps you have a robust pool but not an agile one, so that when a requisition evolves you lack a way to easily source and identify profiles that are relevant given the new requirements.
Two, if your organisation hasn’t designed the most optimum TA operating model or appropriately invested in TA resources, your talent pools will become a static database that requires extensive time and effort to mine.
You need an ATS or CRM that works with you to update profiles using a variety of approaches, such as AI, events, Talent Community sign-up pages, surveys and personal messages with links for candidates to update their information themselves in your database via a portal.
By making these approaches a part of every recruitment campaign—something easy to automate using workflow automation—you can maintain up-to-date databases. Dashboards that permit recruiters and sourcers to view their own data easily can also help them have ownership over redundancies and gaps in their data.
Three, no candidate wants to languish forgotten in a talent pool but yet too many organisations are guilty of these scenarios:

  • Silver-medallist applicants are forgotten when future positions open for which they’d be perfect, or
  • High-quality talent is sending over their CVs but there is not always a role for them when they drop their info in your ATS.

If you never engage with them, when a role does open, how likely will they be to apply again based on the first experience with your company’s application process?
What’s worse, in today’s world they are increasingly likely to share that bad candidate experience on social media, and if your applicant is also a customer, research shows that they are likely to stop buying from you.
Talent pools are effective when you engage with candidates in a reciprocal and relevant way, which can be accomplished by applying recruiting segmentation and automation of basic interactions.

Talent Pools or Talent Pipelines?

Stagnant talent pools will never be effective, which is why the term “talent pipeline,” with its emphasis on movement and interaction, is preferred by some.
Whether pool or pipeline, creating communities is what enables TA practitioners to be ready for, and not reactive to, requisitions. Talent pools enable you to create a curated pipeline of talent who are engaged, qualified and interested in a particular requisition and then share them with hiring managers.
Because you’ve already engaged with and qualified them, candidates in your pipeline have a deeper connection to your employer brand and EVP, which results in more productive  conversations between TA and hiring managers.
High demand necessitates proactive recruiting, whether because of talent scarcity or how critical those people are to your business strategy. Even Google and Amazon, who actually have top talent knocking on their doors, make operational decisions around aggregations of talent. Pooling alone won’t solve TA, but when combined with industry intelligence and executed with the right timing, it becomes a business differentiator.
When TA is executed successfully, it reduces time and cost, drives workforce diversity and innovation, and ultimately boosts business performance. People analytics should inform your strategies for sourcing and attraction, which will in turn affect the size, composition, etc. of your talent pools.
As you analyse historical and predictive data, ask yourself what are your source effectiveness ROIs? How are your conversion ratios from top of funnel to hire? Which KPIs do you segment by job family, geography, etc.? The deltas of these data points should drive decisions as you adjust sourcing strategies for your talent pools development.
Recently I participated in a LinkedIn conversation on the value of talent pooling with Rebecca Houghton and dozens of other HR professionals. Although frustrations with talent pooling were mentioned, I suspect they were mostly due to a lack of effective strategy, optimal operating model, and/or the resources to execute, rather than inherent problems with talent pooling as part of their TA strategy.
What I find extremely interesting is that no one nominated an alternative, so I leave you with this question: assuming your organisation is doing some form of workforce planning (future view of talent demand) which is aligned to the business strategy, other than building talent pools how else can you proactively ensure TA can supply the talent needed to meet that demand?
Cover image: Shutterstock

This article is contributed by Avature.


ATC2019 is all about exploring high performance Talent functions and the elements necessary for Talent Acquisition (TA) to thrive as we enter the age of intelligence. Get your tickets here. 
ATC2019 leaderboard ad

Speakers

Andrew Brockhoff

Andrew Brockhoff

Vice President, Asia-Pacific
Eightfold Ai
Amy Schultz

Amy Schultz

VP Market Development & Operations – RPO, ANZ
Korn Ferry
Chris McDougall

Chris McDougall

Senior Manager – Services Procurement, APAC
KellyOCG
Louise Whitelaw

Louise Whitelaw

Head of Strategy Execution and Innovation, APAC
KellyOCG
Peter Hamilton square

Peter Hamilton

VP and Managing Director, APAC
KellyOCG
Ken MacLeod

Ken MacLeod

Talent Acquisition Manager
Optus
Noel Barret

Noel Barrett

VP APAC
KellyOCG
Liz Eylander

Liz Eylander

Procurement Leader
formerly Medibank
Gary Park

Gary Park

Head of Talent – Mobility & Programmes
V/Line
An image of Steven, a man with glasses and a blue shirt. he is smiling. there is a norfolk pine tree and a cityscape in the background.

Steven Prince

Senior Talent Acquisition Partner
PSC Consulting
Eileen Kovalsky profile

Eileen Kovalsky

Formerly led TA Technology and Candidate Experience transformation
General Motors, USA
Raj Singh square

Raj Singh

Senior Sourcing Lead – Campaigns People & Communications
Health New Zealand | Te Whatu Ora
Athanasia Corso

Athanasia Corso

Head of Talent
InsuranceHouse
rebecca warren

Rebecca Warren

Director, Talent-Centred Transformation
Eightfold
Tash Gawne

Tash Gawne

Chief People Officer
Globird Energy
syed imtiaz

Syed Imtiaz

APAC Talent Acquisition Manager
Siemens
Jay teoh

Jason Teoh

Senior Partner, DE&I Strategy & Governance
Department of Planning, Housing, and Infrastructure – NSW
Jo Vo expanded background (1)

Jo Vohland

The Swiss Army Knife of Talent
ATC Events & Media
Tristan Kolay

Tristan Kolay

APAC Africa Talent Acquisition Lead
Ausenco
Naomi Paik

Naomi Paik

Talent Team Lead
Jo Vohland
Richard Barnett

Sponsors